Creative Dilemma: Determining Authorship Rights in Studio Session Works

Such situations may raise claims of joint authorship and/or copyright infringement, among other things. (A joint copyright owner can't sue a co-owner for infringement, but a court may recognize a joint authorship claim as a distinct alternative from an infringement claim in the same case.) Defendants in these actions may claim an implied license, that the visitor's contribution wasn't original enough to be copyrightable or that the contribution was a work-for-hire under that the defendants own.

These arguments were recently tested in a case involving a recording session for the popular hip-hop artist Jay-Z. Demme Ulloa had been invited to a recording session by Samuel Barnes, who served as a producer for Jay-Z. When Ulloa arrived at the studio, Jay-Z was recording the track “Izzo (H.O.V.A.)” (one not produced by Barnes) that was later released on Jay-Z's “Blueprint” album. The song was made up of a Jay-Z rap over an instrumental riff from the Jackson Five recording “I Want You Back.” While visiting at the studio, Ulloa came up with a countermelody to the instrumental riff that she spontaneously sang with the “Izzo” rap. Jay-Z then asked Ulloa to record the vocal phrase for possible use with the finished recording.