Artist Liability for Audience Injuries

The most recent court ruling on this issue involved the rock group Creed. Christa Harlow attended a 1998 show by Creed at the Webster Theatre in Hartford, CT. Harlow sustained face and head injuries when another concertgoer fell on her from the stage. She then filed a negligence suit in the Superior Court of Connecticut, Judicial District of New Haven, against the band members, the theater and others involved in producing the concert. The complaint alleged that the defendants had “permitted a highly dangerous and violent activity to persist, knew or should have known based on the genre of music and the typical behavior of its audiences that there was a strong likelihood that these dangerous activities would occur at the subject concert and place patrons, such as the plaintiff, at risk of injury.”

The band members moved for summary judgment. Harlow conceded that Creed had not controlled the theater and were not responsible for crowd control or providing security. On the issues of breach and causation, Creed argued that they hadn't engaged in unreasonable or dangerous conduct. The trial court, however, denied the band's summary judgment motion on the ground that there were material facts in dispute on this point. Harlow v. Cee-It-Live LLC, CV000270762S.