Are Prisoners Medical Captives?

In this article, we focus on prospective living organ donors who face capital punishment. Some of the issues raised may also apply to The use of prisoners as living organ donors raises many ethical concerns. As evidenced by the different decisions that have been reached in the cases cited, there is no clear consensus as to how these cases should be handled. Beyond weighing the motives and mental capacity of the prisoner, it is important to determine whether or not someone on death row is capable of giving truly informed consent to the transplant procedure. The fact that donating an organ could prolong an inmate's life can significantly influence the decision, whether by adding a rational incentive in the inmate's best interest, by creating conflict and mixed motives, or by compromising the inmate's decision-making ability even to the extent of exerting undue influence. Moreover, there needs to be an awareness of various secondary gains for a prisoner in consenting to organ donation. Such secondary gains as expressing genuine remorse or salvaging some sense of pride in the face of certain death by engaging in an altruistic act need not be denied to prisoners in the absence of a psychosis that impairs choice behavior.

30 minute readJuly 28, 2005 at 11:39 AM
By
Darlyn Pirakitikulr
Harold J. Bursztajn
Are Prisoners Medical Captives?

The medical treatment of captive patients is a litmus test for a good society. See Bursztajn HJ, Brodsky A: Captive Patients, Captive Doctors: Clinical Dilemmas and Interventions in Caring for Patients in Managed Health Care.

This premium content is locked for LawJournalNewsletters subscribers only

ENJOY UNLIMITED ACCESS TO THE SINGLE SOURCE OF OBJECTIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS, PRACTICAL INSIGHTS, AND NEWS IN LawJournalNewsletters

  • Stay current on the latest information, rulings, regulations, and trends
  • Includes practical, must-have information on copyrights, royalties, AI, and more
  • Tap into expert guidance from top entertainment lawyers and experts
Subscribe Now

Already have an account? Sign In Now

For enterprise-wide or corporate access, please contact Customer Service at [email protected] or call 1-877-256-2473.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2026 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Continue Reading

How Courts Interpret and Apply the Interplay Between the Bankruptcy Code and Medicare Program Act

The combination of increasing operating costs and uncertain government reimbursement funding continues to place health care providers under financial pressure, and in many cases, financial distress. Given the importance of Medicare/Medicaid funding of claims under provider agreements with the federal government, how courts interpret and apply the interplay between the Bankruptcy Code and Medicare Program Act determines the disposition of hundreds of millions of dollars of claims for reimbursement that support the health care system.

April 30, 2026

AI Transparency: Clear Explanations Matter More Than Disclosure

As AI becomes embedded in everyday business and legal operations, organizations are confronting a new expectation: simply disclosing AI use is no longer enough. A critical shift is taking place in the legal industry: transparency is no longer just about disclosure; it’s about comprehension.

April 30, 2026