First and Second Liens

The secured creditors held perfected liens in Westpoint's assets. The Sale Order in Westpoint provided for the sale of the debtor's assets, free and clear of all liens. The Sale Order further provided that secured creditors were to receive cash and replacement liens in the purchaser's securities, and that the cash and securities were deemed to fully satisfy the secured creditors' claims, thus terminating their liens.

The first lien holders appealed the bankruptcy court's approval of the Sale Order, challenging the claim satisfaction and lien termination provisions on the grounds that they effectively converted their interests into an illiquid minority interest in the purchaser. Finding that the distribution provided for under the Sale Order could only take place within the confines of a plan of reorganization, the District Court rejected certain provisions of the Sale Order and remanded the matter to the bankruptcy court. (Ironically, earlier that year, a steering committee of the first lien holders, in collaboration with another entity, had negotiated a proposed transaction with the Debtors which was similar in structure to the transaction ultimately approved by the Sale Order. The proposed transaction would have allowed the Debtors' assets to be transferred under ' 363(b) of the Bankruptcy Code to an affiliate of the steering committee, with the Debtors receiving equity in the affiliate in return. That equity would have in turn been distributed in satisfaction of first lien holder debt, allowing the steering committee, as majority holders of the first lien debt, to control the new company. The bankruptcy court denied the proposed transaction in favor of the auction procedure.)