Error: The field at path '/readnext/contents[5]/uri' was declared as a non null type, but the code involved in retrieving data has wrongly returned a null value. The graphql specification requires that the parent field be set to null, or if that is non nullable that it bubble up null to its parent and so on. The non-nullable type is 'String' within parent type 'Content': {"response":{"errors":[{"message":"The field at path '/readnext/contents[5]/uri' was declared as a non null type, but the code involved in retrieving data has wrongly returned a null value. The graphql specification requires that the parent field be set to null, or if that is non nullable that it bubble up null to its parent and so on. The non-nullable type is 'String' within parent type 'Content'","path":["readnext","contents",5,"uri"],"extensions":{"classification":"NullValueInNonNullableField"}}],"data":{"articleData":{"uri":"/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/","canonicalUrl":"https://www.lawjournalnewsletters.com/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/","generatedId":"glf45ihek","naturalId":"blogAndPostId/blog/post/382-5417","type":"ARTICLE","postFormat":null,"kickerPresentedBy":null,"presentedBy":"","title":"Marvel's Win over Kirby Estate","readtime":"20","timeToRead":"20 minute","prettyModified":"","prettyDateTime":"August 29, 2011 at 02:36 PM","needToKnow":[],"byline":"Jan Wolfe","authors":[{"name":"Jan Wolfe","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/jan-wolfe/"}],"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters","kicker":"Features","kickerNode":[{"name":"Features","slug":"features-kicker","uri":"/features/","sectionName":"Features"}],"prettyDate":"August 29, 2011","pubDate":"2011-08-29 14:36:00:000","modifiedDate":"","isDownload":"false","primaryCategory":{"channelName":"","sectionName":"","name":"","uri":"","slug":"","channelUri":""},"tags":[],"image":{"uri":"","width":"","height":""},"embed1":"","embed2":"","summary":"It's been a good stretch for Marvel Entertainment and its former president Stan Lee, the ever-youthful 87-year old face of the company. Marvel characters Thor and Captain America have dominated the box office. Lee keeps winning over young fans with his blink-and-you'll-miss-them film cameos. Now, thanks to a Stan Lee role on the witness stand, Marvel and its parent The Walt Disney Co. were able claim a win in the courtroom.","categories":[{"name":"Kicker","uri":"///","channelName":"Kicker"},{"name":"Features","uri":"/features/","channelName":"Kicker"},{"name":"Topics","uri":"///","channelName":"Topics"},{"name":"Commercial Law","uri":"/commercial-law/","channelName":"Topics"},{"name":"Litigation","uri":"/litigation/","channelName":"Topics"},{"name":"Sections","uri":"/sections/","channelName":"Sections"},{"name":"News","uri":"/sections/news/","channelName":"Sections"},{"name":"LJN Newsletters","uri":"/ljn-newsletters/","channelName":"LJN Newsletters"},{"name":"Entertainment Law & Finance","uri":"/ljn-newsletters/entertainment-law-and-finance/","channelName":"LJN Newsletters"}],"bodyArray":["

It's been a good stretch for Marvel Entertainment and its former president Stan Lee, the ever-youthful 87-year old face of the company. Marvel characters Thor and Captain America have dominated the box office. Lee keeps winning over young fans with his blink-and-you'll-miss-them film cameos. (Look closely for him as a truck driver trying to dislodge Thor's hammer in Thor or as a general at an award ceremony in Captain America: The First Avenger). Now, thanks to a Stan Lee role on the witness stand, Marvel and its parent The Walt Disney Co. were able claim a win in the courtroom.

","

District Judge Colleen McMahon of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York recently granted summary judgment to Marvel and its league of lawyers at Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker, Haynes and Boone and Weil, Gotshal & Manges, in the declaratory copyright case brought against Marvel by the estate of comic book legend Jack Kirby. McMahon ruled that Kirby's heirs could not claim rights to valuable characters he created for Marvel, like Spiderman, X-Men and the Incredible Hulk. Marvel Worldwide Inc. v. Kirby, 10 Civ. 141. The Paul Hastings team was led by Jodi Kleinick. James Quinn, Randi Singer and R. Bruce Rich represented Marvel at Weil, and David Fleischer at Haynes and Boone worked on the case.

","

Works for Hire

","

Giving considerable weight to two days of testimony from Lee about his arrangements with Kirby and other artists, McMahon held that Kirby created the characters as works for hire, which are excluded from the general rule that a work's creator is its legally recognized author. Had Kirby's heirs prevailed, they stood to collect a windfall, thanks to the provision of the 1976 Copyright Act that lets authors reclaim ownership of pre-1978 copyrights after a 56-year waiting period. Judge McMahon decided, based on the working relationship between Kirby and Marvel: “On the undisputed facts, the Kirby Works were created at the instance and expense of Marvel.” The district judge also noted that a 1972 assignment from Kirby to Marvel “contained an acknowledgement that Kirby had created the works 'as an employee for hire.'”

","

The case is just the latest chapter in the ongoing saga over Marvel's copyrights. In 2002, Lee himself sued Marvel for $10 million, claiming it breached an agreement to pay him royalties from that year's Spiderman blockbuster movie. The dispute settled for an undisclosed amount.

","

In 2009, shareholders of Stan Lee Media Inc. (SLMI), a failed Internet venture Lee launched, sued Marvel for $750 million in profits, claiming Lee assigned SLMI his copyrights. A Manhattan federal judge dismissed that case (see, Abadin v. Marvel Entertainment Inc., 09 Civ. 0715 (S.D.N.Y. 2010)), although the SLMI shareholders continue to litigate the issue of whether Lee assigned his copyrights.

","

The latest ruling was a blow to Kirby heirs' lawyer Marc Toberoff, a film producer living a double life as a copyright crusader. In 2008, Toberoff won a ruling against Warner Brothers that allowed the decedents of Superman co-creator Jerome Siegel to recapture a stake in rights sold more than 70 years ago to DC Comics for $130.

","

In a statement issued following Judge McMahon's ruling, Toberoff targeted “the arcane and contradictory state of 'work for hire' case law under the 1909 Copyright Act. However, the 1976 Copyright Act's termination provisions at issue were specifically designed to correct the unfairness inherent in the author/publisher relationship, and there is no better example of that than Jack Kirby and Marvel.”

","

The Kirby estate has since sent a notice of appeal of McMahon's ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeal for the Second Circuit. Marvel's lawyers declined to comment.

","

Jan Wolfe writes for The American Lawyer, an ALM Media affiliate publication of Entertainment Law & Finance.

","

Works for Hire

","

The Kirby estate has since sent a notice of appeal of McMahon's ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeal for the Second Circuit. Marvel's lawyers declined to comment.

","

Jan Wolfe writes for The American Lawyer, an ALM Media affiliate publication of Entertainment Law & Finance.

"],"altLangHeadline":"","altLangBodyArray":[],"slides":[]},"youmightlike":[{"uri":"/2024/11/01/commercial-property-insurance-how-much-coverage-do-you-really-have/","title":"Commercial Property Insurance: How Much Coverage Do You Really Have?","byline":"Chris Kuleba, Harrell Watts II and Evan Knott","authors":[{"name":"Chris Kuleba, Harrell Watts II","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/chris-kuleba-harrell-watts-ii/","jobTitle":""},{"name":"Evan Knott","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/evan-knott/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"10","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2020/06/insurance6.jpg","width":"616","height":"372"},"summary":"While in many cases involving a substantial property loss the applicable insurance policy limit is clear, in some cases it is not, and the amount to which the policyholder is entitled is governed by a confluence of policy provisions informed by applicable state law."},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/law-firm-real-estate-attorney-offices-are-out-conference-rooms-are-in/","title":"Law Firm Real Estate: Attorney Offices Are Out, Conference Rooms Are In","byline":"Alaa Pasha","authors":[{"name":"Alaa Pasha","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/alaa-pasha/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"5","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2024/10/conference_table.jpg","width":"695","height":"505"},"summary":"Law firms are navigating a paradigm shift in how they approach office space. With the rise of flexible workplaces, firms are finding that when their attorneys do come into the office, the main goal is to connect and collaborate with peers — and this shift has transformed how law firms address their real estate needs."},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/unlocking-your-lawyers-rainmaking-potential/","title":"Unlocking Your Lawyers' Rainmaking Potential","byline":"Yuliya LaRoe","authors":[{"name":"Yuliya LaRoe","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/yuliya-laroe/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"6","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2022/07/money_rain.jpg","width":"616","height":"372"},"summary":"With law firms continuing to face heightened market and industry pressures, business development is essential for both law firm growth and individual lawyer success. However, coaching lawyers to become effective rainmakers presents unique challenges."},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/the-power-of-your-inner-circle-turning-friends-and-social-contacts-into-business-allies/","title":"The Power of Your Inner Circle: Turning Friends and Social Contacts Into Business Allies","byline":"Yuliya LaRoe","authors":[{"name":"Yuliya LaRoe","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/yuliya-laroe/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"9","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2024/10/friends.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"summary":"Practical strategies to explore doing business with friends and social contacts in a way that respects relationships and maximizes opportunities."},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/the-state-of-cost-recovery-post-covid/","title":"The State of Cost Recovery — Post COVID","byline":"Rob Mattern","authors":[{"name":"Rob Mattern","description":"","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/f16d6fc2845f417ea0e93a3f2b6cd37d?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/rob-mattern/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"7","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2023/01/hybrid_work2.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"summary":"Law firm operations are different now. Obviously, the biggest impact of COVID has been the inception and continuation of the hybrid work environment. This has been a kick in the pants for law firms to migrate to a digital working environment"},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/how-can-lawyers-get-client-referrals/","title":"How Can Lawyers Get Client Referrals?","byline":"Bryce Sanders","authors":[{"name":"Bryce Sanders","description":"Bryce Sanders, president of Perceptive Business Solutions Inc., has provided training for the financial services industry on high-net-worth client acquisition since 2001.\r\n\r\nHe trains financial professionals on how to identify prospects within the wealthiest 2%-5% of their market, where to meet and socialize with them, how to talk with wealthy people and develop personal relationships, and how to transform wealthy friends into clients.\r\n\r\nBryce spent 14 years with a major financial services firm as a successful financial advisor, two years as a district sales manager and four years as a home office manager.\r\n\r\nHe developed personal relationships within the HNW community through his past involvement as a Trustee of the James A. Michener Art Museum, Board of Associates for the Bucks County Chapter of the Fox Chase Cancer Center, Board of Trustees for Stevens Institute of Technology and as a church lector.\r\n\r\nBryce has been published in American City Business Journals, Barrons, InsuranceNewsNet, BenefitsPro, The Register, MDRT Round the Table, MDRT Blog, accountingweb.com, Advisorpedia and Horsesmouth.com. In Canada, his articles have appeared in Wealth Professional. He is the author of the book “Captivating the Wealthy Investor.”","imageLarge":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/da8e3db5d322bbb454034067b9a2c542?s=136&d=mm&r=g","webUrl":"/author/profile/bryce-sanders/","jobTitle":""}],"prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","readtime":"4","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2023/11/client6.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"summary":"Getting new business doesn't always involve knocking on doors. It can often be gained by whispering in the right ears."}],"readnext":{"contents":[{"uri":"/2022/01/01/covid-19-and-lease-negotiations-early-termination-provisions/","title":"COVID-19 and Lease Negotiations: Early Termination Provisions","prettyDate":"January 01, 2022","summary":"During the COVID-19 pandemic, some tenants were able to negotiate termination agreements with their landlords. But even though a landlord may agree to terminate a lease to regain control of a defaulting tenant's space without costly and lengthy litigation, typically a defaulting tenant that otherwise has no contractual right to terminate its lease will be in a much weaker bargaining position with respect to the conditions for termination.","description":"During the COVID-19 pandemic, some tenants were able to negotiate termination agreements with their landlords. But even though a landlord may agree to terminate a lease to regain control of a defaulting tenant's space without costly and lengthy litigation, typically a defaulting tenant that otherwise has no contractual right to terminate its lease will be in a much weaker bargaining position with respect to the conditions for termination.","kicker":"Features","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2017/12/contract.jpg","width":"616","height":"372"},"primaryCategory":{"name":"","uri":"","channelName":"","channelUri":""},"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters"},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/how-secure-is-the-ai-system-your-law-firm-is-using/","title":"How Secure Is the AI System Your Law Firm Is Using?","prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","summary":"What Law Firms Need to Know Before Trusting AI Systems with Confidential Information\nIn a profession where confidentiality is paramount, failing to address AI security concerns could have disastrous consequences. It is vital that law firms and those in related industries ask the right questions about AI security to protect their clients and their reputation.","description":"What Law Firms Need to Know Before Trusting AI Systems with Confidential Information\nIn a profession where confidentiality is paramount, failing to address AI security concerns could have disastrous consequences. It is vital that law firms and those in related industries ask the right questions about AI security to protect their clients and their reputation.","kicker":"Features","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2024/05/artificial_intelligence9.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"primaryCategory":{"name":"","uri":"","channelName":"","channelUri":""},"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters"},{"uri":"/2024/10/01/generative-ai-and-the-2024-elections-risks-realities-and-lessons-for-businesses/","title":"Generative AI and the 2024 Elections: Risks, Realities, and Lessons for Businesses","prettyDate":"October 01, 2024","summary":"GenAI's ability to produce highly sophisticated and convincing content at a fraction of the previous cost has raised fears that it could amplify misinformation. The dissemination of fake audio, images and text could reshape how voters perceive candidates and parties. Businesses, too, face challenges in managing their reputations and navigating this new terrain of manipulated content.","description":"GenAI's ability to produce highly sophisticated and convincing content at a fraction of the previous cost has raised fears that it could amplify misinformation. The dissemination of fake audio, images and text could reshape how voters perceive candidates and parties. Businesses, too, face challenges in managing their reputations and navigating this new terrain of manipulated content.","kicker":"Features","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2024/09/harris_trump_767.jpg","width":"767","height":"633"},"primaryCategory":{"name":"","uri":"","channelName":"","channelUri":""},"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters"},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/authentic-communications-today-increase-success-for-value-driven-clients/","title":"Authentic Communications Today Increase Success for Value-Driven Clients","prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","summary":"As the relationship between in-house and outside counsel continues to evolve, lawyers must continue to foster a client-first mindset, offer business-focused solutions, and embrace technology that helps deliver work faster and more efficiently.","description":"As the relationship between in-house and outside counsel continues to evolve, lawyers must continue to foster a client-first mindset, offer business-focused solutions, and embrace technology that helps deliver work faster and more efficiently.","kicker":"Features","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2023/05/collaboration3.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"primaryCategory":{"name":"","uri":"","channelName":"","channelUri":""},"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters"},{"uri":"/2024/11/01/pleading-importation-itc-decisions-highlight-need-for-adequate-evidentiary-support/","title":"Pleading Importation: ITC Decisions Highlight Need for Adequate Evidentiary Support","prettyDate":"November 01, 2024","summary":"The International Trade Commission is empowered to block the importation into the United States of products that infringe U.S. intellectual property rights, In the past, the ITC generally instituted investigations without questioning the importation allegations in the complaint, however in several recent cases, the ITC declined to institute an investigation as to certain proposed respondents due to inadequate pleading of importation.","description":"The International Trade Commission is empowered to block the importation into the United States of products that infringe U.S. intellectual property rights, In the past, the ITC generally instituted investigations without questioning the importation allegations in the complaint, however in several recent cases, the ITC declined to institute an investigation as to certain proposed respondents due to inadequate pleading of importation.","kicker":"Features","image":{"uri":"https://images.lawjournalnewsletters.com/contrib/content/uploads/sites/382/2020/11/itc.jpg","width":"620","height":"372"},"primaryCategory":{"name":"","uri":"","channelName":"","channelUri":""},"publication":"Law Journal Newsletters"},null]}},"extensions":{"DateTime":"2024-11-07T07:57:51.368584879","ResponseTime":"?","AuthorizedUser":false,"AlmContext":"AlmContext{clientIP='10.0.253.239', internalIP='true', origin='', authorizedUser='false', Chinchilla, userAccount='null', UCID=null, ipAccount='null'}","NavServiceResponse":{"message":"Show a wall","action":"show wall","data":"PayWallExcludedClient","placResultsPublic":{"overallContentType":"ExcludedContent","userState":"DENYNOSUB","showWall":"PayWallExcludedClient","userAccess":"0","referrer":"http://www.lawjournalnewsletters.com/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/","userAccessCookie":null,"productList":"","contentMetaData":"

ARTICLE/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/Law Journal Newsletters2011-08-29 14:36:00

Law Journal Newsletters

Kicker

Features

Topics

Commercial Law

Litigation

Sections

News

LJN Newsletters

Entertainment Law & Finance

http://www.lawjournalnewsletters.com/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/

","numberOfViewsLeft":0,"numberOfFCFViewsLeft":0,"decisionEngine":"RidgeRunner","rulesFiredString":"[]","contentProductCodes":"[\"ljnef\",\"//ljnef\"]"}},"DebuggingData":null,"UsedCache":"true","DataUrl":"http://ml.alm.com:9016/bff-services/content/get-you-may-like-for-content.xqy?naturalId=/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/&site=www.lawjournalnewsletters.com&total="},"status":200,"headers":{}},"request":{"query":"query LawJournalNewsletterscom__Article{articleData:\n getContent(naturalId: \"/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/\", site:\"lawjournalnewsletters.com\") {\n uri\n canonicalUrl\n generatedId\n naturalId\n type\n postFormat\n kickerPresentedBy {\n \t\t label\n \t\t value\n \t\t}\n presentedBy\n title\n readtime\n timeToRead\n prettyModified\n prettyDateTime\n needToKnow\n byline\n authors {\n name\n description\n imageLarge\n webUrl\n }\n publication\n kicker\n kickerNode {\n name\n slug\n uri\n sectionName\n }\n prettyDate\n prettyDateTime\n pubDate\n modifiedDate\n isDownload\n primaryCategory {\n channelName\n sectionName\n name\n uri\n slug\n channelUri\n }\n tags\n image {\n uri\n width\n height\n }\n embed1\n embed2\n summary\n categories {\n name\n uri\n channelName\n }\n bodyArray\n altLangHeadline\n altLangBodyArray\n slides {\n image\n caption\n height\n width\n }\n\n\n }\n youmightlike:\n getYouMayLikeForContent(naturalId: \"/2011/08/29/marvels-win-over-kirby-estate/\", site:\"lawjournalnewsletters.com\") {\n uri\n title\n byline\n authors {\n name\n description\n imageLarge\n webUrl\n jobTitle\n }\n prettyDate\n readtime\n image {\n uri\n width\n height\n }\n summary\n }\n readnext:\n getStatsList(site:\"lawjournalnewsletters.com\", topic: \"\", limit: 5, timeframe: \"30days\" ) {\n contents {\n uri\n title\n prettyDate\n summary\n description\n kicker\n image {\n uri\n width\n height\n }\n primaryCategory {\n name\n uri\n channelName\n channelUri\n }\n publication\n }\n\n }\n }"}}

Law.com Subscribers SAVE 30%