Law.com Subscribers SAVE 30%
Call 855-808-4530 or email [email protected] to receive your discount on a new subscription.
New York Federal Jury Rejects First Amendment Defense In 'MetaBirkins' NFT Standoff
Perhaps no other area in the technology sector — save perhaps the recent explosion of generative AI models — has raised as many thorny intellectual property issues as the proliferation of Non-Fungible Tokens, or NFTs, many of which are based on, refer to, or even incorporate, expressive works. Leading the charge have been cases addressing whether NFT makers who utilize other parties' trademarks can turn to the First Amendment as a defense to trademark infringement. This inquiry turns on the now decades-old test established by the Second Circuit in Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989). The Rogers test allows defendants to raise a free speech defense if their use of a mark is artistically relevant to their work and does not explicitly mislead consumers as to its source.
On Feb. 8, 2023, after deliberating for three days, a jury in one such case, Hermès International v. Mason Rothschild, found the defendant — the maker of the infamous "MetaBirkins" NFT collection — liable for trademark infringement, trademark dilution, and cybersquatting, and ordered defendant to pay $133,000 in damages. The jury reached this verdict notwithstanding early rulings in the case by Judge Rakoff, both at the motion to dismiss and summary judgment stages, that the Rogers test potentially protected the defendant's NFTs. Hermès International v. Mason Rothschild, 22-CV-384 (JSR) (U.S. Dist. Ct., Southern District of New York, Feb. 2, 2023).
In contrast, in Yuga Labs v. Ripps, CV-22-4355-JFW-JEM (U.S. Dist. Ct., Central District of California, Dec. 16, 2022), NFT makers tried to justify their use of plaintiff's "Bored Ape" trademarks as commentary against plaintiff's alleged racist tendencies, but the court rejected the defendants' attempt to dismiss the case on free speech grounds under Rogers. The court held that defendants failed to make the threshold legal showing that their use of the marks was part of an expressive work because the defendants' NFTs merely pointed to the same digital images that made up plaintiff's NFT collection, and because defendants' sale of their NFTs amounted to "commercial activities designed to sell infringing products, not expressive artistic speech protected by the First Amendment."
This premium content is locked for Entertainment Law & Finance subscribers only
ENJOY UNLIMITED ACCESS TO THE SINGLE SOURCE OF OBJECTIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS, PRACTICAL INSIGHTS, AND NEWS IN ENTERTAINMENT LAW.
- Stay current on the latest information, rulings, regulations, and trends
- Includes practical, must-have information on copyrights, royalties, AI, and more
- Tap into expert guidance from top entertainment lawyers and experts
Already a have an account? Sign In Now Log In Now
For enterprise-wide or corporate acess, please contact Customer Service at [email protected] or 877-256-2473
How Secure Is the AI System Your Law Firm Is Using?
In a profession where confidentiality is paramount, failing to address AI security concerns could have disastrous consequences. It is vital that law firms and those in related industries ask the right questions about AI security to protect their clients and their reputation.
COVID-19 and Lease Negotiations: Early Termination Provisions
During the COVID-19 pandemic, some tenants were able to negotiate termination agreements with their landlords. But even though a landlord may agree to terminate a lease to regain control of a defaulting tenant's space without costly and lengthy litigation, typically a defaulting tenant that otherwise has no contractual right to terminate its lease will be in a much weaker bargaining position with respect to the conditions for termination.
Pleading Importation: ITC Decisions Highlight Need for Adequate Evidentiary Support
The International Trade Commission is empowered to block the importation into the United States of products that infringe U.S. intellectual property rights, In the past, the ITC generally instituted investigations without questioning the importation allegations in the complaint, however in several recent cases, the ITC declined to institute an investigation as to certain proposed respondents due to inadequate pleading of importation.
The Power of Your Inner Circle: Turning Friends and Social Contacts Into Business Allies
Practical strategies to explore doing business with friends and social contacts in a way that respects relationships and maximizes opportunities.
Authentic Communications Today Increase Success for Value-Driven Clients
As the relationship between in-house and outside counsel continues to evolve, lawyers must continue to foster a client-first mindset, offer business-focused solutions, and embrace technology that helps deliver work faster and more efficiently.